Open Box vs. Refurbished: What's the Difference and Which Is Better?
By Razi Bettani · Published November 20, 2026 · 8 min read · Prices update live
Golootly may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure
Quick answer
Open box means the item was opened, often returned, but barely used. Refurbished means it was used or faulty, then tested, repaired and cleaned before being sold again. Open box is usually closer to new. Refurbished usually comes with more checking and a stronger warranty. If a warranty matters, pick refurbished from a program with written coverage. If you want the newest-looking item, pick open box in the top grade.
Open box vs. refurbished: the difference in one table
The short version: open box is about the box, and refurbished is about the repair. An open-box item may never have been switched on. A refurbished item was almost always used or sent back with a problem, and someone has worked on it since.
| Open box | Refurbished | |
|---|---|---|
| Where it comes from | Returns, display models, damaged packaging | Returns, trade-ins, faulty or used units |
| Work done on it | Usually a check, a reset and repacking | Tested, repaired if needed, cleaned, reset |
| Typical condition | Close to new, but depends on the grade | Anywhere from like new to visible wear, by grade |
| Warranty | Often the maker's warranty, but not always | Usually a program or seller warranty, length varies |
| Best for | Gifts, items you want to look new | Phones, laptops and pricier tech where coverage matters |
What does open box mean?
An open-box item is one whose package has been opened, so the store can't sell it as new anymore. Most of the time, a customer bought it, changed their mind and returned it. Some are floor or display models, and some just arrived with a crushed box.
Stores grade open-box stock so you know what you're getting. Best Buy, for example, uses three grades: Excellent, Good and Fair. It says all three work like new and are reset to factory settings, and the grade tells you about looks and missing pieces. Excellent should look like new with everything included. Good can have small scratches and may be missing non-essential parts or the original box. Fair can have bigger marks and missing accessories. The price changes with the grade.
One thing to know: "open box" has no single legal meaning. Every store uses its own rules, so the grade name only helps if you read that store's definition.
What does refurbished mean?
A refurbished item was used, returned with a problem, or traded in, and then restored so it can be sold again. That normally means it was tested, repaired if something was wrong, cleaned and reset. How much work goes in depends on who did it.
- Manufacturer refurbished. The brand restores its own product. Apple, for example, says its Certified Refurbished products use genuine Apple parts where needed, refurbished iPhones and other iOS devices get a fresh battery and a replacement outer case, and every one comes with Apple's standard one-year limited warranty.
- Store program refurbished. A big store sets the rules and vets the sellers. Amazon Renewed, Walmart Restored and eBay Refurbished all work this way, each with its own grades and protection.
- Seller refurbished. An independent shop does the work. Quality can be great or poor, so the seller's ratings and written warranty matter most here.
Is open box better than refurbished?
Neither one wins every time. Open box is usually better when you want something that looks and feels new, and refurbished is usually better when you want proof that the item was checked and a warranty behind it. Here's how to choose for your situation:
- Ask how bad a breakdown would be. For a laptop, phone or TV, a written warranty is worth more than a slightly nicer case. For a cheap kitchen gadget, the return window is usually enough.
- Compare against today's new price, not the list price. If the new item is on sale, the open-box or refurbished discount may shrink to almost nothing. Example: if a new pair of headphones is $100 and the open-box pair is $80, you save 20%. If the new pair drops to $85, you only save $5.
- Add the cost of anything missing. A missing charger, remote or cable can wipe out the saving once you replace it.
- Check who backs the warranty. "Warranty included" means little until you know who honors it and for how long.
How big U.S. stores label open box and refurbished
Each store uses different names, grades and protection. This is what their own pages say. Policies change, so confirm on the listing before you buy.
| Store / program | What it sells | Grades | Protection |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best Buy Open-Box | Returns, display models, damaged boxes | Excellent, Good, Fair | Same return window as new items; often the maker's warranty |
| Amazon Renewed | Refurbished items from qualified sellers | Condition shown on each listing | Amazon Renewed Guarantee: refund or replacement within 90 days |
| Walmart Restored | Refurbished items from vetted sellers | From Premium down to Fair | Inspected, tested and cleaned; 90-day returns |
| eBay Refurbished | Refurbished items from brands and vetted sellers | Certified, Excellent, Very Good, Good | Warranty serviced by Allstate: 2 years (Certified) or 1 year (others); 30-day free returns |
| Apple Certified Refurbished | Apple products restored by Apple | One standard | One-year limited warranty; free shipping and returns |
Notice the pattern: store-run refurbished programs tend to spell out their protection, while open-box warranty is usually "often, but check." Best Buy itself says many open-box products keep the maker's warranty and tells you to confirm it on the item.
What about used, pre-owned and renewed?
These words get mixed up all the time. Here's how they usually differ:
- Used and pre-owned mean the same thing in most listings: someone owned it, and nobody promises it was repaired. "Pre-owned" just sounds nicer.
- Renewed is Amazon's name for refurbished, and Restored is Walmart's. Both are refurbished programs with their own rules.
- Certified refurbished usually means the brand or an approved partner did the work, and it typically comes with the strongest warranty of the group.
- Like new isn't a standard term. One store's "like new" can be another store's "very good," so read the description, not just the label.
Checklist before you buy open box or refurbished
- You know who is selling it: the store, the brand or an outside seller.
- You've read the grade definition on that store's own page.
- You know what's missing (charger, remote, cables, manual, box).
- You know the return window and whether the item is final sale.
- You know the warranty length and who honors it.
- The price beats today's new price by an amount that matters to you.
- For phones, you've checked that it's unlocked or works with your carrier.
- You'll test it the day it arrives, well inside the return window.
The bottom line
Open box gets you closest to new for less, but protection depends on the store. Refurbished gets you a checked, repaired item, and the best programs back it with a written warranty. For expensive tech, pick a refurbished program with clear coverage. For gifts or items where looks matter, pick top-grade open box. In both cases, compare against today's new price first. For more ways to save, browse our electronics deals, clearance deals and store coupons, or read how Walmart clearance works.
Sources
- Best Buy: Open-Box items and conditions
- Best Buy: Return and exchange policy
- Amazon Renewed: FAQ and Renewed Guarantee
- Walmart Restored
- Walmart: Walmart Restored launch announcement
- eBay Refurbished: grades, warranty and returns
- Apple: About Apple Certified Refurbished
Golootly isn't connected to any of these stores and doesn't sell anything. Policies were checked on November 20, 2026 and can change, so confirm the details on the store's page before you buy. As an Amazon Associate, Golootly earns from qualifying purchases.
Frequently asked questions
+Is open box the same as refurbished?
No. Open box means the package was opened, usually because the item was returned, but it was barely or never used. Refurbished means the item was used or faulty and has since been tested, repaired if needed and cleaned before being sold again.
+Is open box better than refurbished?
It depends on what matters to you. Open box is usually closer to new in looks. Refurbished usually gets more testing and a clearer warranty. For expensive tech like phones and laptops, a refurbished program with written coverage is often the safer pick.
+Do open-box items come with a warranty?
Often, but not always. Best Buy says many of its open-box products keep the same manufacturer warranty as new ones, but it tells shoppers to confirm this on each item. Check the listing or ask the brand before you buy.
+Can you return open-box and refurbished items?
Usually, yes. Best Buy applies the same return window to open-box and refurbished items as to new ones, Walmart Restored offers 90-day returns, and eBay Refurbished offers 30-day free returns. Final-sale items are the exception, so read the listing.
+What is the difference between refurbished and pre-owned?
Pre-owned is another word for used: someone owned the item and nobody promises it was repaired. Refurbished means the item was tested, fixed if needed and cleaned before resale, and it usually comes with some kind of warranty.
Read next
How Walmart Clearance Works: Tags, Returns & Live Deals
Markdowns in rounds, tags that lag behind the register, and what Walmart's own return policy says about clearance.
Keep reading


